mirror of
https://github.com/bitcoin/bips.git
synced 2026-06-01 17:15:27 +00:00
bip-0054: mention Luke's extranonce concern in rationale
This commit is contained in:
10
bip-0054.md
10
bip-0054.md
@@ -118,7 +118,13 @@ early [bip-0034][BIP34] violations also allows applications to recover the block
|
||||
having to parse Script. Leveraging the existing timelock mechanism makes the check self-contained:
|
||||
the same coinbase transaction cannot have been valid in a previous block[^11]. This simplifies both
|
||||
reasoning and client implementation, since the [bip-0030][BIP30] check can be skipped entirely past
|
||||
Consensus Cleanup activation, regardless of the [bip-0034][BIP34] activation status[^12].
|
||||
Consensus Cleanup activation, regardless of the [bip-0034][BIP34] activation status[^12]. One person
|
||||
[raised the concern][miningdev nLockTime] that the `nLockTime` field would be an ideal extranonce
|
||||
for ASIC controllers if such controllers ever became a bottleneck in mining operations. Others
|
||||
[replied][miningdev nLockTime] that the same benefits could be achieved by using a dummy output
|
||||
instead, should that ever become necessary. The authors [believe][ML remaining concerns] the
|
||||
benefits of using `nLockTime` to differentiate coinbase transactions outweigh the theoretical
|
||||
cost of making it unavailable for extranonce rolling by ASIC controllers.
|
||||
|
||||
## Backward compatibility
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -251,3 +257,5 @@ MERKLEBLOCK] for a full description.
|
||||
[inquisition-implem]: https://github.com/darosior/bitcoin/tree/2509_inquisition_consensus_cleanup
|
||||
[Core 30.0]: https://bitcoincore.org/en/releases/30.0
|
||||
[Core validation.cpp BIP34]: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/390e7d61bd531505bb3d13f38316c282b85ed1dd/src/validation.cpp#L2401-L2459
|
||||
[miningdev nLockTime]: https://groups.google.com/g/bitcoinminingdev/c/jlqlNHHNSNk
|
||||
[ML remaining concerns]: https://gnusha.org/pi/bitcoindev/UsKuvCXXhSAnNVx5a0K2UfP3srAr3slW9mcOjtYk9LnolaOXfWrW9jpqbxsQQPkyQuZogkhz2Hbfwii2VsTm79vRDpgKduxk35hpBu_t7Do=@protonmail.com/
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user