Inviting a member to a group that already had members put nothing whatsoever in
the transcript. Not "put it in late" -- nothing, and nothing ever if the invite
did not complete. So the one failure the user is best placed to notice, an
invite that never reached the person it was made for, was the one the app kept
to itself.
The line existed. It was written by `MarmotOutboundDao.deliveryWelcome`, which
is the wrong place for it, and the reason is the two paths through
`inviteMember` that docs/marmot-membership.md already describes. A group that is
still only its creator has nobody to inform, so its Welcome goes out immediately
and `deliveryWelcome` runs inside the invite. A group that has members must
broadcast a commit first, and its Welcome waits for a relay to acknowledge it --
`DatabaseNostrRepository.broadcastProcessed` picks the stored `MarmotCommitResult`
back up and delivers then. Every invite after a group's first therefore wrote
its transcript line a relay round trip away from the invite, if at all.
**Four separate silences, not one.** Worth listing because only the first is
about the deferral, and fixing that alone would have left the other three:
1. The deferred path wrote nothing until the ack, and nothing ever without one.
2. The write hung off `getMarmotKeyPackageById(...)?.let { getProfileByPublicKey(...)?.let { ... } }`.
Those two lookups were there to *name* the invitee, and a miss on either cost
the whole line rather than just the name.
3. `deliveryWelcome` wraps its body in `catch (e: Throwable) { logger.e(...) }`
and returned Unit, so a Welcome that could not be built reached the log and
no further.
4. `inviteMemberToChatRoom` is `@Transaction`. An invite that threw -- no MLS
state for the room, a credential identity that does not match the peer --
rolled its line back with everything else, which is right, and left no
account of the refusal anywhere durable.
And the line it did write was `messageType = "message"`, `isUserMessage = true`,
so it rendered as a chat bubble: "Invited Bob to chat", attributed to the
inviter as something they said.
**Three membership types, and the line moves to invite time.**
`ChatMessage.MEMBERSHIP_TYPES` -- `memberInvited`, `memberInviteSent`,
`memberInviteFailed` -- rendered by the transcript as system notices through
`RitualNotice`, the way the ceremony, signing and chronicle lines already are.
`memberInvited` is written by `inviteMember` and by `addMembersToChatRoom`'s
batch path, *when the invite is made*, and deliberately **inside** the caller's
transaction. Both halves of that matter and they pull opposite ways: written any
later and an invite waiting on an ack that never comes shows nothing, which is
the bug; written outside the transaction and an invite that does not survive
`addMember` leaves the room claiming one was made.
`memberInviteSent` is written by `DatabaseNostrRepository` alone. It is not
written on the immediate path, and that is not an oversight: there the Welcome
goes out in the same breath as the invite, so one line is the whole truth. It
would also be a line the transcript could not order -- `MantraConverters` stores
`Instant` as `epochSeconds`, the room query is `ORDER BY createdAt DESC`, and two
rows written in the same second tie. Only the deferred path separates the two
events in time, so only it owes a second line.
`memberInviteFailed` carries the reason, because it is the only copy the user
gets. `deliveryWelcome` now returns `Boolean` and files this line from its own
catch before returning false -- its callers had no other way to see a failure it
had already swallowed, and on the deferred path there is no invite screen left
to fail back to. `addMembersToChatRoom` reads that answer instead of a
`runCatching` that could never catch anything.
**The refusal is written from outside the transaction that rolled it back.**
`DatabaseChatRepository.inviteMember` catches, calls `announceInviteFailed`, and
rethrows. The throw is what puts a message on the invite screen now; the line is
what is still there tomorrow. Swallowing it instead would have popped the user
back to the chat as though the invite had gone out, which is the bug the
existing `runCatching` in `AddMemberToChatRoomConfirmationViewModel` was added
to stop.
**No schema change.** `messageType` is a free-form string column with a default,
so new values need no migration -- unlike the chronicle rename, which had to
rewrite the ones already stored. Nothing reindexes these either: they carry no
`marmotGroupEventId`, so `getResolvedMarmotGroupEventIds` cannot see them and
`UNRESOLVED_MARMOT_TYPES` does not name them.
Six new tests. Four on the DAO: the immediate path leaves a line naming the
invitee where the old code left none, the deferred path leaves one *and* claims
no Welcome sent before any ack, everything an invite writes is a membership type
rather than something the transcript would render as a bubble, and a refused
invite leaves no claim that one was made. Two new ones on
`DatabaseChatRepository`, which had no test file: a refused invite is written
into the room, and the caller still gets the throw.
Still open, and now said plainly in the doc rather than implied: a Participant
row carries no state saying where its invite got to. The transcript narrates it;
the `TODO: Update status of participant Invitation.PENDING -> Invitation.SENT`
is untouched. Nor does an invitee with no published key package reach the room
at all -- that fails in the view model, before there is an invite to write a
line about.
806 tests pass -- 509 jvm, 297 android.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
98f766fcd3