Phase 1 is implemented and verified in the lightning-kmp-app fork on claude/jvm-target-actuals (27a0054). Four things in the plan were wrong, and doing the work is what surfaced them. **jvm() belongs at the start of phase 1, not phase 4 -- for the library.** The plan said leave it off in both builds until phase 4. That is right for mantra and wrong for the fork: library/src/jvmMain/ is an orphan source set until the library declares the target, so phases 1-3 would all have been written blind. Declared first, `:library:compileKotlinJvm` names the remaining expects, and that list beats grepping for `expect ` -- it shrinks by exactly what you implement and cannot drift from the truth. The build stays red across phases 1-3 by design. That checklist is now recorded as the phase 1 exit condition: exactly eight expects should remain, and exactly which eight. Anything else means something in the phase is wrong. **Phase 3 is two decisions, not four.** gracefulSingleSeedDecryption and gracefulMultiSeedDecryption are pure exception mapping into a DecryptSeedResult, and the exception they branch on is java.security.KeyStoreException -- a plain JCA type that exists on the jvm. Both are near-copies of the android actuals and need nothing settled first, so they move alongside phase 2. Only keyStoreEncryption and keyStoreDecryption are the security decision, and that part of the analysis stands. **The Fibonacci template must not be deleted.** The plan said to drop it "assuming nothing references them". Things do: generateFibi is exercised by template tests in commonTest, androidHostTest, iosTest, jvmTest and linuxX64Test, and JvmFibiTest asserts a value that depends on precisely the two properties fibiprops.jvm.kt defines. That file already satisfies two of the 25 expects, which is why the count was 23 missing rather than 25. Removing the template is five test files plus four fibiprops.* actuals, and it is a separate cleanup. **Phase 1 is fifteen actuals, not fourteen**, and two of them are not copies of android -- platformElectrumRegtestConf (10.0.2.2 is the emulator's alias for the host loopback; a jvm process is already on the host) and phoenixLogWriters (android routes kermit into slf4j because android tooling reads that back). Also recorded, because it cost time: a worktree cannot run gradle at all until the submodules are checked out *and* local.properties exists at five levels. Neither is version controlled, so a fresh worktree has neither, and the failure surfaces four builds down at :...:secp256k1-kmp:jni:android as "SDK location not found" rather than anywhere obviously related. Both builds were run: `:library:compileKotlinJvm` fails only on the known eight, and `:composeApp:compileDebugKotlinAndroid` still passes with the library's jvm target declared -- the check that matters, since a new variant must not change how the android target resolves the library. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
22 KiB
Bringing up the JVM target
What it would actually take to build Mantra for desktop, phased, with the blocking work separated from the mechanical work.
The headline is not what you would expect. The four-deep native chain — secp256k1 → bitcoin-kmp → lightning-kmp → lightning-kmp-app — is already building for JVM, and has been all along. The thing standing in the way is an empty source set in our own phoenix fork.
One scoping note before anything else: none of this is needed to test the
DAOs. Host-speed Room tests run under androidUnitTest today, given one extra
dependency. The JVM target is a product decision — a desktop Mantra — not a
testing prerequisite. See Room DAO tests
at the end.
What is already done for you
The native chain is already JVM. This is the expensive part, and it is
finished. The comment at composeApp/build.gradle.kts:50
records why: lightning-kmp-core publishes no android variant, so our android
target resolves it to the jvm one, which in turn pulls
secp256k1-kmp-jni-jvm — desktop .so/.dylib/.dll files. That is why the
build has to name secp256k1-kmp-jni-android by hand.
Read that the other way round and it is good news: every JVM artifact in the chain is already compiled from source, by the composite build, on every android build we do. Turning on a JVM target adds no cinterop, no C compilation, and no new native constraints.
The third-party dependencies all have JVM variants. Verified against the repositories the build actually resolves from:
| dependency | JVM artifact | status |
|---|---|---|
| quartz 1.14.0 | com.vitorpamplona.quartz:quartz-jvm |
on Maven Central |
| room3 3.0.1 | androidx.room3:room3-runtime-jvm |
on Google Maven |
| sqlite 2.7.0 | androidx.sqlite:sqlite-bundled-jvm |
on Google Maven |
| sqldelight 2.3.2 | app.cash.sqldelight:jdbc-driver, :sqlite-driver |
on Maven Central |
commonMain is clean. No android.* and no java.* imports anywhere in it.
The three NFC files in androidMain are not referenced from common code either,
so there is nothing to stub out and no android-only API to route around. The
shared tree will compile for JVM as-is.
What actually blocks it
lightning-kmp-app/library declares 25 expect symbols in commonMain and
implements them across 35 files in androidMain. Its jvmMain contains exactly
one file:
// lightning-kmp-app/library/src/jvmMain/kotlin/fibiprops.jvm.kt
package io.github.kotlin.fibonacci
actual val firstElement: Int = 2
actual val secondElement: Int = 3
That is the Kotlin multiplatform library template's Fibonacci boilerplate, left over from whenever the module was scaffolded. It implements two of the 25 expects, and both of them are the template's own.
So 23 JVM actuals are missing, one level down from us, and
lightning-kmp-app/library/build.gradle.kts:18 has jvm() commented out because
of it. Mantra cannot declare jvm() — commented out in turn at
composeApp/build.gradle.kts:46 — until phoenix
does.
Everything below is ordered by that dependency.
Phase 0 — build configuration
~half a day. No blockers.
Nothing here needs a decision; it is the groundwork the later phases assume.
-
Delete the stale
jvmMaintree. Six files undercomposeApp/src/jvmMain/kotlin/ac/cord/auxiliary/survive from the old Aux project. They are an orphan source set that nothing currently compiles, which is why they have gone unnoticed — they use the wrong package, importandroidx.room(Room 2), and reference a long-goneAuxDatabase. The momentjvm()is declared they become compile errors.Keep them open in a scratch buffer while doing Phase 4: five of them are a usable skeleton for the actuals we still need.
-
Add the missing catalog entries to
gradle/libs.versions.toml:androidx-sqlite-bundled-jvm = { module = "androidx.sqlite:sqlite-bundled-jvm", version.ref = "sqlite" } sqldelight-sqlite-driver = { module = "app.cash.sqldelight:sqlite-driver", version.ref = "sqldelight" }Only these two, and only because neither can be reached any other way.
sqlite-bundled-jvmhas to be named explicitly because variant-aware resolution hands the android artifact to anything running on the host — that is the whole trap described in the appendix.sqlite-driveris the jvm counterpart to theandroid-driverandnative-driverentries already here.No
room3-runtime-jvmentry: oncejvm()exists,commonMain's existingandroidx-room3-runtimeresolves to the-jvmvariant on its own. And the SQLDelight drivers Phase 2 needs belong in lightning-kmp-app's own catalog, not this one — that is a separate gradle build with a separate version catalog, and putting them here would not make them visible there. -
Do not wire
kspJvmyet. It cannot be done at this point, and the reason is already written down a few lines above it in the build file:These configurations only exist when the ios targets are declared, which the kotlin block above does only on a mac.
The same rule governs
kspJvm—dependencies { add("kspJvm", ...) }throwsUnknownConfigurationExceptionuntil ajvm()target creates that configuration. So uncommenting composeApp/build.gradle.kts:194 belongs in Phase 4, in the same edit that turns the target on, not here. -
Leave
jvm()commented out, in both builds. It goes on at the start of Phase 4, once there is something for it to resolve against. Turning it on earlier just means living with a broken build through Phases 1–3.
Verification: ./gradlew :composeApp:compileDebugKotlinAndroid still passes.
This phase changes nothing observable; the point is that it changes nothing
observable — a deleted orphan source set and two unreferenced catalog entries
cannot alter a build.
If you are working in a git worktree, no gradle task will run at all until
the submodule is checked out there. Worktrees do not get submodules
automatically, so lightning-kmp-app/ is empty and the composite build fails
during configuration:
Project with path ':library' not found in build ':lightning-kmp-app'
git submodule update --init --recursive fixes it, but note that a linked
worktree shares .git/modules/ with the main checkout, so both trees end up
sharing one submodule git dir. That is fine while both want the same commit —
check with git submodule status in each — and worth being careful about when
they do not.
Then the fresh clones need local.properties, which is gitignored and therefore
absent, at five levels — the mantra root and each of the four nested builds
down to secp256k1-kmp. Without it configuration fails at
:lightning-kmp-app:lightning-kmp:bitcoin-kmp:secp256k1-kmp:jni:android with
"SDK location not found":
for d in . lightning-kmp-app \
lightning-kmp-app/experimental/lightning-kmp \
lightning-kmp-app/experimental/lightning-kmp/experimental/bitcoin-kmp \
lightning-kmp-app/experimental/lightning-kmp/experimental/bitcoin-kmp/experimental/secp256k1-kmp; do
echo "sdk.dir=$HOME/Android/Sdk" > "$d/local.properties"
done
Phase 1 — phoenix: the mechanical actuals
~1–2 days. Blocked by nothing. Do this first.
Start by turning on jvm() in the library —
lightning-kmp-app/library/build.gradle.kts:18, not mantra's, which still waits
for Phase 4. Without it library/src/jvmMain/ is an orphan source set that
nothing compiles, and every actual in Phases 1–3 would be written blind. With it,
./gradlew :library:compileKotlinJvm prints the remaining expects by name, and
that list is a better worklist than any grep — it shrinks by exactly what you
implement and cannot drift from the truth.
Fifteen of the 23 are mechanical. None requires a decision — each is either a direct copy of the android implementation or a few lines of JVM file handling.
DbHooks.jvm.kt — six functions, and this one is free. The android
implementation is 15 lines and every function is an empty body; the hooks only do
work on Apple platforms, where they drive CloudKit sync. Copy the file, change
the suffix.
actual fun didSaveWalletPayment(id: UUID, database: PaymentsDatabase) {}
actual fun didDeleteWalletPayment(id: UUID, database: PaymentsDatabase) {}
actual fun didUpdateWalletPaymentMetadata(id: UUID, database: PaymentsDatabase) {}
actual fun didSaveContact(contactId: UUID, database: PaymentsDatabase) {}
actual fun didDeleteContact(contactId: UUID, database: PaymentsDatabase) {}
actual fun makeCloudKitDb(appDb: SqliteAppDb, paymentsDb: SqlitePaymentsDb): CloudKitInterface? = null
PlatformContext.jvm.kt — the class plus four directory paths. On android
these come off a Context; on desktop there is no context object, so
PlatformContext becomes either an empty class or one holding an explicit root
directory. Prefer the latter — it makes tests and multi-profile desktop installs
possible later, and it costs nothing now.
The four paths (getApplicationFilesDirectoryPath,
getDatabaseFilesDirectoryPath, getApplicationCacheDirectoryPath,
getTemporaryDirectoryPath) should resolve to a per-OS application data
directory, not java.io.tmpdir. The old Aux code used tmpdir and left a TODO
about it; do not inherit that.
The remaining singles: platformElectrumRegtestConf (not a copy — android
uses 10.0.2.2, the emulator's alias for the host loopback, and a jvm process is
already on the host), AppVersion, phoenixLogWriters (kermit's CommonWriter;
android routes into slf4j because android tooling reads that, and the jvm has no
equivalent convention), and computePreferencePath.
Leave the Fibonacci template alone. fibiprops.jvm.kt looks like stray
scaffolding, but it is the jvm half of a pair: generateFibi is exercised by
template tests in commonTest, androidHostTest, iosTest, jvmTest and
linuxX64Test, and JvmFibiTest asserts a value that depends on exactly the two
properties that file defines. It already satisfies two of the 25 expects, which
is why 23 are missing rather than 25. Deleting the template is a reasonable
cleanup of a lightning wallet library, but it is five test files plus four
fibiprops.* actuals, and it is not this work.
Verification: ./gradlew :library:compileKotlinJvm from inside
lightning-kmp-app/. It still fails at the end of this phase — that is expected,
and the failure is the point. It should report exactly eight remaining
expects, and they should be exactly the contents of Phases 2 and 3:
DbFactory.kt createChannelsDbDriver, createPaymentsDbDriver, createAppDbDriver
NetworkMonitor.kt NetworkMonitor
KeyStoreFunctions.kt keyStoreDecryption, keyStoreEncryption
TechnicalExtensions.kt gracefulSingleSeedDecryption, gracefulMultiSeedDecryption
Anything else in that list means something in this phase is wrong. Also re-run
./gradlew :composeApp:compileDebugKotlinAndroid from the mantra root: adding a
jvm target to the library must not disturb how the android target resolves it.
Phase 2 — phoenix: drivers and connectivity
~2–3 days. Blocked by nothing, but do it after Phase 1.
Three of the 23 are database drivers and one is the network monitor. These are real implementations, but they are bounded — the shape is known and the failure modes are ordinary.
DbFactory.jvm.kt — createChannelsDbDriver, createPaymentsDbDriver,
createAppDbDriver. Use SQLDelight's sqlite-driver (the JDBC driver
specialised for SQLite). The one real difference from android: the android driver
creates and migrates the schema for you via AndroidSqliteDriver's callback, and
the JDBC driver does not. You call Schema.create(driver) and the migration path
explicitly, and you have to track the applied version yourself. Budget for that,
not for the driver construction.
createPaymentsDbDriver also takes an onError: (String) -> Unit — make sure
corruption and migration failures actually reach it rather than throwing past it,
because on android that callback is what surfaces the problem to the user.
NetworkMonitor.jvm.kt. The android implementation is 90 lines built on
ConnectivityManager and its NetworkCallback — genuine push notification of
connectivity changes. The JVM has no equivalent. The options are a polling
reachability check, or treating the connection as always-available and letting
the lightning stack's own reconnect logic handle reality.
Start with polling on a slow interval. It is worse than the android behaviour and that is acceptable — the alternative is pretending the network never changes, which produces confusing UI on a laptop that gets closed and reopened.
Verification: none of this is exercisable until Phase 4. Write the SQLDelight
schema-creation path against a scratch main() if you want feedback sooner.
Phase 3 — phoenix: key storage
A decision, not a port. Unbounded until the decision is made.
Four of the 23, but only two of them are actually a decision.
gracefulSingleSeedDecryption and gracefulMultiSeedDecryption are not. They
are pure exception mapping into a DecryptSeedResult, and the exception they
branch on is java.security.KeyStoreException — which exists on the jvm, since
KeyStore is a plain JCA type. Both are a near-copy of the android actuals and
can be written before any of the below is settled. Do them with Phase 2 and leave
two errors outstanding rather than four.
The decision is keyStoreEncryption and keyStoreDecryption.
The android implementation delegates to KeystoreHelper.kt — 116 lines against
AndroidKeyStore, with KeyGenParameterSpec, and setIsStrongBoxBacked(true)
attempted first and fallen back from when the device has no secure element. The
key material never leaves hardware.
Desktop JVM has no equivalent. There is no portable, hardware-backed keystore on the JVM. The realistic options:
| approach | protects against | cost |
|---|---|---|
| passphrase-derived KEK (Argon2id → AES-GCM) | disk theft, if the passphrase is strong | low; but prompts the user on every launch |
| OS keychain via JNA (Keychain / DPAPI / libsecret) | other users on the machine, at rest | three separate platform integrations, three failure modes |
| JCEKS/PKCS12 file with a fixed key | nothing meaningful | low, and misleading |
This is wallet seed material. The third option is not a stopgap, it is a liability, and it interacts directly with the plaintext-key finding already open against this codebase — do not let a desktop build quietly become the weakest place the seed lives.
Recommendation for sequencing: implement the passphrase-derived KEK, mark the desktop build clearly as unsuitable for real funds, and treat OS-keychain integration as its own piece of work with its own review. That unblocks Phases 4 and 5 without pretending the security question is answered.
This phase is the only one in the plan with no honest day estimate, because the estimate is a function of which row of that table gets chosen and how much review it attracts.
Phase 4 — mantra's own actuals
~1–2 days. Blocked by Phases 1–3.
Now turn on jvm() — composeApp/build.gradle.kts:46
and lightning-kmp-app/library/build.gradle.kts:18 — and, in the same edit,
uncomment kspJvm at composeApp/build.gradle.kts:194.
Those two go together: the KSP configuration does not exist until the target
does, which is why Phase 0 deliberately left it alone. Then let the compiler
drive.
Mantra declares 16 expects across 8 files. They split cleanly:
Six platform basics. getPlatform (Platform.kt),
PlatformContext, AppVersion, themeColorScheme
(Theme.kt),
and PlatformDatabaseBuilder's two functions. The deleted Aux files from Phase 0
are a working skeleton for five of these — repackage to press.mantra.compose,
update Room 2 → Room 3 (androidx.room → androidx.room3), and point at
MantraDatabase instead of AuxDatabase.
MantraDatabaseConstructor needs no hand-written actual; Room's KSP generates it
once kspJvm is wired above.
For PlatformDatabaseBuilder.getDatabaseBuilder, use the real application data
directory from Phase 1 — not java.io.tmpdir, which is what the old Aux
implementation did and which silently loses the database on reboot on most
systems.
Nine lightning wrappers. Four in
Phoenix.kt
(platformStartupLogic, schedulePlatformLogic, getShowIntroFlow,
getGlobalPrefs) and five declared in
SovereignWalletViewModel.kt
(updateBusinessActiveInUI, loadAndDecryptSeed, getAvailableWalletsMeta, and
the two saveAvailableWalletMeta overloads, plus platformWriteSeed) whose
android actuals live in NavigationViewModel.android.kt.
These are thin — they mostly forward into the phoenix library. They are thin because Phases 1–3 did the work, which is why they are last.
schedulePlatformLogic is the one to look at properly: on android it schedules
background work through WorkManager. On desktop there is no equivalent and no
process that outlives the window. Decide explicitly whether it becomes a no-op or
an in-process coroutine, and write down which.
Verification: ./gradlew :composeApp:compileKotlinJvm. This is the first
point in the plan where the JVM target has to actually resolve, so expect the
dependency-substitution surprises to land here rather than earlier.
Phase 5 — desktop entry point and shakeout
~1–2 days. Blocked by Phase 4.
composeApp/build.gradle.kts:221 already names
press.mantra.desktop.MainKt as the desktop main class. That file does not
exist. Write it: a application { Window { ... } } entry point constructing
PlatformContext and handing it to the same root composable android uses.
The UI itself is Compose Multiplatform and should largely come up as-is. What to expect anyway:
- Window sizing. The layouts have only ever been laid out at phone widths. Nothing will crash; plenty will look wrong.
- Back handling. Android's system back has no desktop counterpart.
- NFC. The three
androidMainNFC files are correctly android-only and are not referenced fromcommonMain— but any UI that offers an NFC affordance needs to not offer it here. Dispatchers.IO. Used ingetRoomDatabaseand available on JVM, so no change; noted because it is not available on all KMP targets and is easy to trip over later.
Verification: ./gradlew :composeApp:run.
Estimate
| phase | work | days | blocked by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | build configuration | 0.5 | — |
| 1 | phoenix: mechanical actuals (14) | 1–2 | — |
| 2 | phoenix: drivers + network (4) | 2–3 | — |
| 3 | phoenix: key storage (4) | decision | — |
| 4 | mantra actuals (16) | 1–2 | 1, 2, 3 |
| 5 | desktop entry point + shakeout | 1–2 | 4 |
Roughly one focused week to a launchable desktop build, assuming Phase 3 takes the passphrase-derived KEK and the build is marked dev-only. Real desktop key storage is separate work that should not be folded into this estimate, and should land before anyone holds funds on a desktop Mantra.
Phases 1, 2 and 3 are independent of each other and can go in parallel if more than one person is on it. Phase 4 cannot start until all three are done, because it is where the compiler finally checks the whole thing.
Out of scope
linuxX64()— commented out in the phoenix library at line 53. A native Linux target is a different problem from a JVM one and buys nothing here.- iOS on a Linux host — still impossible, for the reasons already documented in both build files. The JVM target does not change that.
- Publishing desktop distributables — the
compose.desktopblock already declares Dmg/Msi/Deb formats, but signing, notarisation and update channels are untouched by this plan.
Appendix: Room DAO tests do not need this
Worth stating plainly, because the two questions arrived together and the answer to one is not the answer to the other.
Room's own testing guidance
recommends host-machine tests over instrumented ones. We can have those today,
without a JVM target, because room3-runtime-android:3.0.1 exposes the
no-Context builder overload:
inMemoryDatabaseBuilder(kotlin.jvm.functions.Function0<? extends T>)
and MantraDatabaseConstructor.kt
already supplies what it needs. So Room.inMemoryDatabaseBuilder<MantraDatabase>()
compiles in commonTest and runs under testDebugUnitTest.
The one trap is native, and it is the same shape as the secp256k1 problem documented in the build file — in the opposite direction:
| artifact | ships |
|---|---|
sqlite-bundled-android |
jni/{arm64-v8a,armeabi-v7a,x86,x86_64}/libsqliteJni.so |
sqlite-bundled-jvm |
natives/{linux_x64,linux_arm64,osx_*,windows_x64}/ |
A local unit test resolves the android variant, whose .so files the host JVM
cannot load, so BundledSQLiteDriver() fails at construction. Naming
sqlite-bundled-jvm on the androidUnitTest classpath fixes it.
Robolectric does not help and is not needed — it cannot load android .so on the
host either, and Room's guidance advises against it regardless.