043d725599920070a0e42154d3c212d57ca6d49e
2 Commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Kgothatso Ngako
|
8cd0f3f44d |
refactor: take the last 353 spacing literals onto the scale, and reach zero
Phase 2, final step, of docs/material-design-conformance.md. Every `.dp` literal in a
spacing position in the UI tree is now a token. 431 reads of `MaterialTheme.spacing.*`, one
reasoned exemption, and `m3-spacing-positions.py` exits 0.
**Shape decides the token, not just the value.** The migration script grew a per-shape
mapping because the same number means different things in different positions: 8dp of
padding is `compactPadding`, 8dp of gap is `itemGap`, and 8dp under a `Spacer` is neither
of those and stays `space100`. Where the pair determines the meaning the semantic name is
used, and nowhere else:
padding + 8dp -> compactPadding 10 sites
padding + 16dp -> containerPadding 10
gap + 4dp -> relatedGap 8
gap + 8dp -> itemGap 10
That is 38 of 353. The rest take the raw stop, and deliberately: assigning a semantic name
needs somebody to have read what the container *is*, and a name that asserts a meaning the
code does not have is worse than a stop that asserts none. `screenMargin` in particular is
unassignable mechanically -- it is 16dp of padding, exactly like `containerPadding` -- so
it has no call sites yet and gets them when someone reads the screens.
**Two spacers were standing in for zero.** `WriteNewNoteScreen` renders
`Spacer(Modifier.height(1.dp))` twice, in the `LazyColumn` item that shows a reply preview
when there is one. There is nothing to show and the item still has to render something;
1dp was the placeholder. Now `space0`, with a comment, because a 1dp gap that nobody
intended is the kind of thing that gets copied.
**One value is exempt, and says so at the site.** `SovereignWalletStartupScreen`'s
`Spacer(Modifier.height(128.dp))` is room to scroll the last wallet clear of the bottom of
the window -- reserved space, not a step in the rhythm. The scale tops out at `space900`
(72dp) and rounding to it would put the row back under the edge.
Rather than exempt it in the script by value, the classifier now honours an inline
`// m3-spacing-exempt: <reason>` comment on the lines directly above. Exemptions belong at
the call site: the reason travels with the code, a reviewer sees it in the diff that adds
it, and the tool stops accumulating a list of numbers that mean nothing on their own -- the
mistake the first version of this audit made with `DIMENSION_EXEMPT`.
**Where the tokens landed.** `space125` (10dp) 128 times and `space250` (20dp) 107 -- the
two values that already dominated the tree, now named. `space600` (48dp) 52 times, which is
the empty-state spacer from the previous commit. The long tail is 2, 4, 6, 12, 14, 16, 24,
32, 40 and 64dp.
**Verified that nothing moved.** The landing screen was captured on emulator-5554 before
and after and compared pixel by pixel on a 4px grid: **47 differing samples out of
162,000, 0.03%**, and they are the status bar clock. The sweep is a rename.
**Budget ratcheted 353 -> 0**, dated in the file. Phase 8 wires `--check` into CI, at which
point a new `.dp` in a `padding()` fails the build.
**Tests.** 942 pass, 594 jvm over 72 classes and 348 android over 44, unchanged --
`SpacingScaleTest` already asserts the scale, and there is nothing to assert about a
call site having been renamed that the compiler does not.
`:composeApp:compileDebugKotlinAndroid` builds, the debug apk installs and runs,
`m3-audit.sh --check` exits 0. 75 files, 432 insertions, 348 deletions.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
||
|
Kgothatso Ngako
|
f7a732d68a |
refactor: move the 89 off-grid spacing values onto the M3 scale
Phase 2, second step, of docs/material-design-conformance.md. 77 of the 89 literals that
were off M3's spacing scale sat in spacing positions and now read
`MaterialTheme.spacing.spaceNNN`; the remaining 12 are dimensions and are out of scope.
One drifted corner moved onto the shape scale.
**The mapping, and why each is the nearest stop rather than the nicest number.**
5.dp x10 -> space50 (4dp) padding and gaps in dense rows
15.dp x14 -> space200 (16dp) card and dialog padding, two gaps
30.dp x1 -> space400 (32dp) the spacer under LoadingDataIndicator's spinner
50.dp x52 -> space600 (48dp) the spacer above an empty or error message
Nearest-stop throughout, so the largest move is 2dp and most are 1. `5.dp` is equidistant
between `space50` and `space75`; it goes to 4dp because `spacedBy(4.dp)` is already the
idiom elsewhere in the tree and a scale with two answers for the same input is not one.
The 52 at 48dp are the same three lines copied into 16 files -- a `Spacer` pushing
"Something went wrong" down the screen. Phase 5 retires them into a shared empty-state
composable; migrating them first means that composable inherits a token rather than
another literal.
**One shape, and it is the argument for having a scale at all.**
`RoundedCornerShape(30.dp)` in `TextNoteEventDetail` was the only hand-written corner off
the M3 scale, at 30dp against `extraLarge`'s 28. Two units: invisible beside any single
other card, and exactly the drift that happens when the value is a literal. It is now
`MaterialTheme.shapes.extraLarge`, the first call site for the scale `Shape.kt` documented.
**Rewritten by a script that reads call shapes, not values, and it is checked in.**
`docs/scripts/m3-migrate-spacing.py` brace-matches three call shapes -- `padding(...)`/
`PaddingValues(...)`, `Arrangement.spacedBy(...)`, and a `.height()`/`.width()` whose
enclosing call is `Spacer(` -- and rewrites only literals that fall inside one. A
`.size(18.dp)` icon, a non-Spacer `.height()`, a `RoundedCornerShape` or a `BorderStroke`
can never be caught, which a regex over `\\d+\\.dp` would have done to all of them. It
inserts the two imports where they are missing and skips comment lines. Dry run by default.
**The audit was measuring the wrong thing, and this is where that showed.** It split
literals by value against a hardcoded `DIMENSION_EXEMPT` list -- and the split is not a
property of the value. `16.dp` is a spacing stop *and* a plausible icon size. `50.dp` was a
`Spacer` height in 52 places and a divider width in one, and no list of numbers separates
those. `docs/scripts/m3-spacing-positions.py` replaces it with the same brace-matching
parse the migration uses, so the audit and the migration agree by construction; the audit
now reports **353 spacing literals** left and 76 dimensions out of scope, and the exemption
table is gone.
That reframes phase 2's acceptance criterion into something checkable: spacing positions to
zero, dimensions untouched. The script exits 1 while any spacing literal remains.
**What is left off-scale, and why none of it is a defect.** Twelve dimensions: avatar sizes
at 35, 55, 70 and 75dp, icon sizes at 18 and 22dp, and a 50dp divider width. Avatar and
icon sizing is a component-spec question rather than a spacing one -- M3 gives icons 18/20/
24/40/48 and says nothing about avatars -- and the plan puts per-component specs after the
adaptive phase. They are reported rather than exempted so the number stays visible.
**Tests.** 942 pass, 594 jvm over 72 classes and 348 android over 44, unchanged --
this commit adds no assertions, and the ones it could add (`SpacingScaleTest`) landed with
the scale. `:composeApp:compileDebugKotlinAndroid` builds, `m3-audit.sh --check` exits 0.
Pixels move by at most 2dp, in 30 files.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|