From afc443b0eefd02ef25396eb8cf625f3b5990a353 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kgothatso Ngako Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 07:17:15 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] docs: plan a parent choosing its subgroups' guardian delay, and saying it in time A parent picks its own leaf's delay when it makes a guarded subgroup, from 6 blocks to 65,535 (BIP68's block-based ceiling, about 15 months); an inherited ancestor keeps the delay it chose. The delay rides the ceremony proposal, is signed into the certificate's guardian tag and checked by both quorums, and every screen that quotes "12" says each leaf's own delay as blocks with an approximate duration. Eight phases, not built. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- docs/README.md | 5 + docs/guardian-delay.md | 629 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 634 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/guardian-delay.md diff --git a/docs/README.md b/docs/README.md index 0b691620..afb95ef2 100644 --- a/docs/README.md +++ b/docs/README.md @@ -15,6 +15,7 @@ silent, or a decision that looked arbitrary and was not. | [group-send-an-amount.md](./group-send-an-amount.md) | sending an amount in sats from the group's wallet, with change — why the gate as written could never lift and is removed in favour of the mainnet cap, the decimal point the gated form multiplies by ten, and change addresses reserved like coins | | [group-wallet-guardians.md](./group-wallet-guardians.md) | letting an ancestor group spend from a subgroup's wallet through a taproot leaf — why the parent signs the guardian keys into the child's certificate, why every inherited key is derived one step further per child, and why every ancestor waits 12 blocks | | [subgroup-wallet-policy.md](./subgroup-wallet-policy.md) | the parent deciding, at a subgroup's birth, whether its wallet is guarded or unguarded — why the choice is signed three times, why *unguarded* means no keys in the certificate, why a guarded group's subgroups are all guarded, and why the rule is every honest client's rather than the chain's | +| [guardian-delay.md](./guardian-delay.md) | a parent choosing how long a coin waits before a guardian can take it, from 6 blocks to BIP68's 65,535 -- why each ancestor keeps the delay it chose as its key goes down the tree, what a long delay gives the child, and how a number of blocks is said in time | | [group-wallet-addresses.md](./group-wallet-addresses.md) | listing the group wallet's receive addresses as Phoenix lists its swap-in ones — why the list stops at the current address plus two, why a paid address past that still shows, and why a used address can be copied but never shown as a QR code | | [frost-session-resend.md](./frost-session-resend.md) | asking the members who never got a signing proposal to look again — why a proposer can repeat only what it wrote, why a member's availability signal needs no repeating, and the one half that has to come from the silent member's own device | | [marmot-membership.md](./marmot-membership.md) | how members join an MLS group, and the epoch race that makes a missing member look like a successful invite | @@ -57,6 +58,10 @@ The subgroup-wallet-policy note is a phased plan that has been built. It reads as the guardians note's *whose choice it is* reversed: read that section, then this note's Phase 0, whose five decisions shape every phase after it, and its table of where the build chose differently before the code. +The guardian-delay note is a phased plan that has not been built. It changes +the guardians note's *Why 12, and why for everybody* and reuses the +wallet-policy note's plumbing one field further: read both, then its table of +what is already per leaf, then its Phase 0. The Material Design note is a phased plan that has not been built, and is the only one about what the app looks like rather than what it does; read the jvm-target note first if you want to know why its adaptive-layout phase exists. diff --git a/docs/guardian-delay.md b/docs/guardian-delay.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c3d03196 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/guardian-delay.md @@ -0,0 +1,629 @@ +# The parent sets the delay: how long a coin waits before a guardian can take it + +Today every leaf in a guarded wallet is ` OP_CHECKSIGVERIFY 12 +OP_CHECKSEQUENCEVERIFY`: any ancestor can take a coin once it has 12 +confirmations, about two hours. Twelve is one constant, +`GuardianDerivation.ANCESTOR_DELAY`, the same for every ancestor at every +distance. This plan lets a group choose that number for its own leaf when it +makes a guarded subgroup. The floor is **6 blocks**. The ceiling is **65,535 +blocks**, the largest relative lock BIP68 can express in blocks. Everywhere the +app shows a delay, it also shows roughly how long that is in minutes, hours, +days, months or years, whichever reads best. + +The headline: **the parent chooses its own leaf's delay on the subgroup picker, +next to the choice of a guarded wallet. The choice rides the ceremony proposal, +the parent's quorum signs it into the birth certificate as the delay on the +parent's guardian tag, and the child's quorum signs it again. An inherited +ancestor's leaf keeps the delay that ancestor chose, so each group's terms +follow its key down the tree.** + +Read [group-wallet-guardians.md](./group-wallet-guardians.md) and +[subgroup-wallet-policy.md](./subgroup-wallet-policy.md) first. This builds on +the guardian tag from the first and the wallet-policy plumbing from the second, +and it changes one section of the first: [*Why 12, and why for +everybody*](./group-wallet-guardians.md#the-leaf). + +**Not built.** Written against the code as it stood at `60cb3fa7`, schema v29. + +--- + +## What is already per leaf, and what is not + +Less of this is new than it sounds. The guardians work wrote the delay into +every tag precisely so that a later delay would be "a later account's tags, not +a new format", and most of the code already reads it from there: + +| piece | today | +|---|---| +| `GuardianTag` | `["guardian", , , , ]`. `parse` already accepts 1 to 65,535 | +| `GuardianDerivation.Guardian.delay` | a field, defaulting to `ANCESTOR_DELAY` | +| `GuardianDerivation.leafScript` | already writes 1 to 16 as `OP_1`…`OP_16` and anything above as a minimal number push, and refuses anything outside 1 to 65,535 | +| `grantedTo` | `copy(...)` of the guardian, so an inherited key already keeps its delay one step down | +| `descriptorTree` | `older(${guardian.delay})` | +| `GroupSpend.check` | reads the spender's own leaf's delay and requires every input's sequence to equal it | +| `GroupSpendBuilder.lockOf` | per leaf: offers a guardian only coins at least that deep, and puts that sequence on every input | +| fee sizing, `GroupSpend.kt:390` | built from the real leaf script, so a longer number push is already counted | +| `GuardianManager.takenIn` | rebuilds each leaf from its own delay | + +What still assumes 12: + +| piece | where | +|---|---| +| `grant()` | the parent's own new entry takes the default, `ANCESTOR_DELAY` | +| `refuseCertificate` | compares the proposal to `grant()`, so any own delay other than 12 is refused | +| `GuardedWalletRow.withinReach` | `confirmations >= ANCESTOR_DELAY` (`GroupWalletUIState.kt:89`) | +| every string that quotes a delay | the picker (`SelectSubgroupAdminsScreen.kt:395`), the join gate (`DkgJoinApprovalScreen.kt:78`), the wallet screen (`GroupWalletScreen.kt:386`, `:408`, `:461`, `:672`), and six strings in `strings.xml` that say `%1$d confirmations` as if there were one number | +| the guardians note | *Why 12, and why for everybody* | + +So the work is three things: let the parent choose, carry the choice to +everybody who signs it, and stop every screen from saying "12". + +--- + +## The limits + +### The floor: 6 blocks + +About an hour. It keeps the property the guardians note gives as the reason for +a delay at all: **the child's own spends always go first.** A guardian cannot +race the child for a payment that has only just arrived, nor take the change +from a spend the child made a few minutes ago. Below about six blocks, one block +found quickly or a short reorg can put a fresh coin within a guardian's reach +before the child has had a chance to act on it. + +### The ceiling: 65,535 blocks + +BIP68 gives a relative lock 16 bits of `nSequence`. With the type flag (bit 22) +clear, the value counts blocks: 1 to 65,535, which is about 455 days, or a +little over 15 months. That is the most the protocol can express **for a lock +that counts from the coin's own confirmation**, which is the kind the guardian +leaf has to be. + +Two other locks look longer and are not the same thing: + +- **BIP68 in time units** (bit 22 set) counts 512-second steps, also 16 bits. + Its ceiling is 65,535 × 512 s, about 388 days, so it is *shorter* than the + block form. It also measures median time past rather than blocks. Not used. +- **An absolute lock** (`OP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY`) can name any height or date, + but it counts from a fixed point rather than from the coin. A leaf with one + would become spendable by the guardian for every coin at once, on one day, + however recently each arrived. That is a different promise, and it is listed + under [what this does not do](#what-this-does-not-do). + +Staying at or below 65,535 also keeps two other things true without extra +checks: + +- **bit 22 is never set**, so the number is always read as blocks; +- **the sequence stays far below `GroupSpend.MAX_SEQUENCE`** (`0xfffffffd`), so + a guardian spend still signals replaceability and *Bump the fee* still works. + +### The encoding, at its edges + +Script numbers are little-endian, sign-and-magnitude, minimally encoded. +`Script.encodeNumber` in bitcoin-kmp already does this, including the zero byte +a positive number needs when its top byte has the high bit set. The cases a test +has to pin, because each is where the encoding changes length: + +| delay | `` in the leaf | leaf script | +|---|---|---| +| 6 | `OP_6` | 36 bytes | +| 16 | `OP_16` | 36 bytes | +| 17 | `0x01 0x11` | 37 bytes | +| 127 | `0x01 0x7f` | 37 bytes | +| 128 | `0x02 0x80 0x00` | 38 bytes | +| 32,767 | `0x02 0xff 0x7f` | 38 bytes | +| 32,768 | `0x03 0x00 0x80 0x00` | 39 bytes | +| 65,535 | `0x03 0xff 0xff 0x00` | 39 bytes | + +A guardian input therefore costs at most three weight units more than it does +today. That is under one vbyte, and it is paid only when a guardian spends. + +--- + +## What a longer delay changes, said plainly + +The guardians note is candid that two hours is not autonomy: "two hours is not +long enough for a child to notice a coin coming within reach and move it." +That stops being true as the delay grows, and the picker has to say so. + +**The clock is per coin, and spending resets it.** A coin moved by the child is +a new coin, confirmed afresh. So a child that spends, or merely moves, each coin +before it is `d` blocks old keeps every coin out of every guardian's reach for +as long as it keeps doing that. With `d = 12` that would mean a transaction +every two hours, which is not practical. With `d = 4,320`, about a month, it +means one consolidation a month, which is cheap. + +So the choice is a real trade, and the picker's description says both halves: + +| delay | the guardian is | the child is | +|---|---|---| +| short (hours) | an override: in practice it can take any coin the child has not just received | under the guardian's control | +| long (months) | a backstop: it reaches coins the child has left alone for that long, such as a dormant wallet or a group that has stopped meeting | able to keep its coins out of reach by moving them before the lock runs out | + +A long delay is the right choice for a parent that wants a recovery path for a +subgroup that falls silent, and the wrong one for a parent that wants to be able +to take funds back from a subgroup that is still active. + +--- + +## Phase 0 — decisions, before any code + +Six, each with a recommendation. The phases below assume the recommended answer. + +### D1. Whose delay does the parent choose? + +**Recommended: its own leaf's only. An inherited key keeps the delay its +ancestor chose.** + +With root → middle `M` → grandchild `C`: + +``` +cert(M), signed by root: [ root/i(M) delay d₁ ] root chose d₁ +cert(C), signed by M: [ M/i(C) delay d₂, M chooses d₂ + root/i(M)/i(C) delay d₁ ] passed down unchanged +``` + +`grantedTo` already copies the delay, so this is what the code does today, with +every `d` equal to 12. It keeps each delay the decision of the group whose leaf +it is: the root decided how long a coin in `M`'s subtree waits for the root, and +`M` cannot shorten or lengthen that. Under the wallet-policy plan's D4 a guarded +group can only make guarded subgroups, so the root's terms reach every guarded +descendant of `M` unchanged. + +The alternative is one delay per certificate, chosen by the parent, applying to +every leaf. It is simpler to show, since a wallet then has one number. But it +lets `M` rewrite the root's terms in `C`'s wallet. A short `d₂` would bring the +root's reach closer than the root chose for `M`, and a long `d₂` would push it +further away. Neither was the root's decision. Rejected. + +### D2. The range + +**Recommended: 6 to 65,535, as `GuardianDerivation.MIN_DELAY` and `MAX_DELAY`, +enforced by the parser as well as the picker.** `GuardianTag.parse` and +`leafScript` move from `1..0xFFFF` to `MIN_DELAY..MAX_DELAY`. Every guardian tag +in existence says 12, so tightening the parser breaks nothing that was ever +written. A tag under 6 from a modified client then fails to read, and the +existing rule handles it: the certificate's guardian list reads as null, so the +wallet-policy read is null and `GroupKeyStateManager.parentageOf` drops the key +state. + +### D3. The default + +**Recommended: 12, unchanged.** It is what every existing guarded wallet uses, +and the guardians note gives the reasons for it. `ANCESTOR_DELAY` is renamed +`DEFAULT_DELAY`, because it is no longer the delay, only the one offered first. + +### D4. How the picker asks + +**Recommended: presets plus a custom number of blocks.** + +| preset | blocks | shown as | +|---|---|---| +| 1 hour | 6 | about 1 hour | +| 2 hours (default) | 12 | about 2 hours | +| 1 day | 144 | about 1 day | +| 1 week | 1,008 | about 7 days | +| 1 month | 4,320 | about 1 month | +| 6 months | 26,280 | about 6 months | +| longest | 65,535 | about 15 months | +| custom | 6–65,535 | the field's supporting text, live | + +A slider over 6 to 65,535 is unusable at the short end, where most choices are, +and a logarithmic one shows the user numbers they did not pick. Presets cover +what people mean. The custom field is for the exact number, and says what it +works out to while it is being typed. + +### D5. How a delay is said in time + +**Recommended: "about", the largest unit that makes the number at least 2, and +exactly one of a unit when the delay is within 5% of it.** The rule, at 10 +minutes per block, with a month of 30.44 days and a year of 365.25: + +1. If the delay is within ±5% of exactly one hour, day, month or year, use that + unit, singular: *about 1 day*. +2. Otherwise use the largest of years, months, days, hours and minutes in which + the delay comes to at least 2, rounded to the nearest whole: *about 36 hours*, + *about 3 months*. + +Worked through: + +| blocks | exact | shown | +|---|---|---| +| 6 | 60 min | about 1 hour | +| 12 | 2 h | about 2 hours | +| 100 | 16.7 h | about 17 hours | +| 144 | 1 day | about 1 day | +| 216 | 1.5 days | about 36 hours | +| 1,008 | 7 days | about 7 days | +| 4,320 | 30 days | about 1 month | +| 13,140 | 91 days | about 3 months | +| 26,280 | 182.5 days | about 6 months | +| 52,560 | 365 days | about 1 year | +| 65,535 | 455 days | about 15 months | + +Years appear only near exactly one year, because the ceiling is 1.25 years, and +"about 15 months" says more than "about 1 year". Weeks are left out: the units +asked for were minutes, hours, days, months and years. Adding weeks later is one +more row in the rule, for example "about 2 weeks" instead of "about 14 days". + +**Always beside the block count, never instead of it.** Blocks are what the +script enforces. Ten minutes is the average, not a promise, so a delay of 144 +blocks can take 20 hours or 30. The text reads *144 blocks, about 1 day*. + +**Regtest shows blocks only.** Its blocks arrive when somebody mines them, so a +time estimate there would be wrong. Signet and the testnets use the same +10-minute target as mainnet and get the estimate. The picker always uses +mainnet's estimate, because a certificate is not for any one network. + +### D6. Fixed at birth + +**Recommended: yes, like the wallet policy.** The delay is part of the guardian +tag, the guardian tag is part of the certificate the child's key state carries, +and the guardians note's rule 2 fixes an account's guardian set, delays +included, at its first statement. Changing a delay means a new subgroup. + +--- + +## Phase 1 — the range, and the parent's own delay, pure + +In `GuardianDerivation`: + +```kotlin +const val MIN_DELAY: Long = 6L +/** BIP68's block-based relative lock is the low 16 bits of nSequence. */ +const val MAX_DELAY: Long = 0xFFFFL +const val DEFAULT_DELAY: Long = 12L // was ANCESTOR_DELAY +val DELAY_RANGE: LongRange = MIN_DELAY..MAX_DELAY + +fun grant( + thresholdPublicKey: HexKey, + ownChatRoomId: String, + inherited: List, + childChatRoomId: String, + delay: Long = DEFAULT_DELAY, // the parent's own leaf, D1 +): List +``` + +- `grant` requires `delay in DELAY_RANGE` and puts it on the first entry only. + The inherited entries go through `grantedTo`, unchanged, and keep theirs. +- `leafScript` requires `DELAY_RANGE` instead of `1..0xFFFF`. +- `GuardianTag.parse` reads only delays in `DELAY_RANGE` (D2). +- `Guardian.delay` keeps its default, renamed to `DEFAULT_DELAY`, so no caller + that builds a guardian by hand changes. +- The class comment and the KDoc on the old constant are rewritten. "One value + for every ancestor at every distance" stops being true. + +**Tests**, `GuardianDerivationTest`: +- the encoding table above, byte for byte, through `Script.write(leafScript(...))`; +- `grant(..., delay = 4_320)` puts 4,320 on the parent's entry and leaves an + inherited entry at the delay it arrived with; +- `descriptorTree` writes `older(65535)` and passes bitcoin-kmp's descriptor + checksum; +- 5 and 65,536 are refused by `grant`, `leafScript` and `GuardianTag.parse`. + +One commit. Nothing chooses a delay yet. + +--- + +## Phase 2 — the script enforces it, at every edge + +A jvmTest in the shape of `GuardianSpendRoundTest`. For each delay in `[6, 16, +17, 127, 128, 32_767, 32_768, 65_535]`, a parent quorum's shares sign a +script-path spend of a child's coin. Then: + +- `Transaction.correctlySpends` accepts the spend at `nSequence = delay` and + refuses it at `delay - 1`; +- `GroupSpend.check` refuses an input whose sequence is not the leaf's delay; +- `GroupSpendBuilder.spendable` offers a coin with `delay - 1` confirmations to + nobody but the owner, and offers it to the guardian at `delay`. + +This is the phase that would catch an encoding mistake before a coin could. A +leaf whose lock is pushed non-minimally is a coin nobody can spend through that +leaf. + +--- + +## Phase 3 — saying a delay in time + +New, pure, in `wallet/`: + +```kotlin +object BlockDuration { + const val MINUTES_PER_BLOCK = 10 + + enum class Unit { MINUTES, HOURS, DAYS, MONTHS, YEARS } + data class Approximate(val count: Int, val unit: Unit) + + /** D5's rule. */ + fun approximate(blocks: Long): Approximate +} +``` + +And one composable beside the other text helpers: + +```kotlin +@Composable +fun delayText(blocks: Long, chain: Chain?): String // "144 blocks, about 1 day"; regtest: "144 blocks" +``` + +The units are **plurals**, the catalogue's first: `` and the rest, with `one` and `other`, read through +`pluralStringResource`. A plain `%1$d hours` string reads *about 1 hours*, and +the sentence-case audit cannot catch that. `StringCatalogueJvmTest` gains a +case asserting that plurals resolve on the JVM, as CLAUDE.md asks. + +**Tests**, `BlockDurationTest`: every row of D5's table, both edges of each ±5% +window (for example 137 and 151 blocks for *one day*), and the full range from 6 +to 65,535 never returning a count of 0 or a unit above years. + +--- + +## Phase 4 — the ceremony carries the delay + +The same path the wallet policy took in the policy plan's Phase 2, one field +further: + +- `DkgRitualEvents`: a `["guardian_delay", ""]` tag on a subgroup's + ceremony proposal, written only beside `["wallet", "guarded"]`; +- `ChillDkgRitualManager.proposeRitual(guardianDelay: Long?)`. It requires null + unless the policy is `GUARDED`, and a delay in `DELAY_RANGE` when it is set, + checked before the running-ceremony lookup as the policy is; +- `acceptProposal` files it, and drops a proposal whose delay does not read, + falls outside the range, or comes without a guarded policy; +- **Schema 29 → 30**: the nullable `DkgSession.guardianDelay`. Null for every + ceremony before this and for every unguarded one, an auto-migration like the + policy's. + +A guarded ceremony from a build that has the policy and not the delay carries no +delay. It is certified at `DEFAULT_DELAY`, which is what that build would have +written. + +**Tests**, in `SubgroupCeremonyInParentRoomTest`: the delay travels on the +proposal and nowhere else, and lands on every admin's session; a delay with an +unguarded policy, a delay of 5, and `"twelve"` are each dropped; a guarded +proposal with no delay files null. + +--- + +## Phase 5 — the picker, and the join gate + +### `SelectSubgroupAdminsScreen` + +Under the *Guarded wallet* row, shown only while it is selected, a *How long +before the groups above can spend a coin* section: + +- D4's presets as a row of `FilterChip`s, wrapping, the default selected; +- *Custom* opens an `OutlinedTextField` with a number keyboard. Its supporting + text is the live `delayText` while the value is in range, and the reason + (*at least 6 blocks*, *at most 65,535 blocks*) while it is not; +- under both, one line of D1's consequence for the parent's own leaf, and + [the trade above](#what-a-longer-delay-changes-said-plainly) in a sentence: + *A coin the subgroup moves starts waiting again, so a long delay lets it keep + its coins out of reach by moving them.* + +The description on the guarded row stops quoting one number. It lists the +parent's own delay, plus *and the N groups above it, on the terms they set* +when the parent's own certificate carries guardians. The picker reads those +terms from `ChatRepository.guardiansOf`, which it already calls. + +In `SelectSubgroupAdminsViewModel`: + +- `guardianDelay: MutableState`, starting at `DEFAULT_DELAY`; +- `setGuardianDelay` clamps nothing and stores what was typed, because the field + has to be able to show *at most 65,535* about the number the user actually + entered; +- `refusal()` refuses an out-of-range delay under a guarded policy, before the + key-package wait, as the policy refusals are; +- `prefillFromRetry` restores the delay from the failed ceremony; +- `confirm` passes it, and passes null for an unguarded subgroup. + +CLAUDE.md applies in full: chips and the field from `material3`, spacing from +`MaterialTheme.spacing`, strings and plurals in the catalogue in sentence case, +and the custom field with a real label and supporting text, not a placeholder. + +### `DkgJoinApprovalScreen` + +The guarded line gains the delay: *The subgroup's wallet will be guarded: this +group can spend a coin in it once it has 144 confirmations, about 1 day.* An +inherited ancestor's terms are not on this screen, because a member deciding +whether to join cannot check them. They are on the wallet screen, from the +verified certificate, in Phase 7. + +**Tests**, `SelectSubgroupAdminsViewModelJvmTest`: the default is 12; a preset +and a typed delay are what `refusal()` judges; 5 and 65,536 are refused with +their reasons; a retry restores the delay; an unguarded subgroup confirms with +no delay. + +--- + +## Phase 6 — the certificate carries it, and both quorums check it + +### Proposing + +`SubgroupManager.proposeBirthCertificate` reads `key.guardianDelay` off the +child's ceremony, as it reads the policy, and passes it to `grant`: + +| ceremony | certificate's own entry | +|---|---| +| guarded, delay `d` | `d` | +| guarded, no delay (older build) | `DEFAULT_DELAY` | +| unguarded | no guardian tags at all, as today | + +### Every parent signer + +`refuseCertificate` stops comparing the whole proposal to `grant()` with the +default. Instead: + +- the first entry's delay is in `DELAY_RANGE`, which reading the tag already + guarantees under D2; +- the proposal equals `grant(..., delay = proposed.first().delay)`. The key, the + chain code and the order are checked exactly as before. The **inherited** + entries' delays must be exactly the ones on the group's own certificate, + because `grant` copies them, so a proposer cannot shorten the root's wait in + the grandchild's wallet (D1). + +The existing test case *a shorter delay*, `copy(delay = 1)`, keeps refusing, +now because 1 is out of range. Two cases are added: +- an inherited entry with its delay changed is refused; +- an own delay of 4,320 is accepted. + +### What the parent's admins read + +`ProposedEvent`'s certificate summary says the delay on the parent's own leaf: +*this group can spend from its wallet once a coin has 144 confirmations, about +1 day*. `ProposedEvent` is not a composable, so it uses +`BlockDuration.approximate` with fixed English words, as the rest of that file +does. + +### Every child signer + +`SubgroupManager.refusePolicy`, behind `refuseKeyState`, also requires the +certificate's first guardian delay to equal the ceremony's announced +`guardianDelay`, when there is one. This is the same consent rule as the policy: +the admins were shown the number at the join gate, and joining was agreeing to +it. + +**Tests**, in `SubgroupManagerJvmTest`: each row of the proposing table; +`refuseCertificate`'s new cases; a key state whose certificate carries 12 under +a ceremony that announced 4,320 is refused by `refuseKeyState`. + +--- + +## Phase 7 — every screen says each leaf's own delay + +Once a wallet can hold leaves with different delays, no sentence with one +`%1$d` in it is true any more. + +**The child's wallet screen** (`GroupWalletScreen`, `OpenWalletAction` and the +guarded wallet's header). The sentence that quotes one number becomes a list +under it, nearest ancestor first, one row per guardian: + +``` +Guarded + #Council after 144 blocks, about 1 day + #Ekklesia after 4,320 blocks, about 1 month +``` + +The names come from the rooms the device has, falling back to *a group above +this one*. The shortest delay is the one that matters most to the child, so the +section title says it: *The groups above can spend a coin from 144 +confirmations, about 1 day*. + +**An ancestor's *Guarded wallets* list** (`:672`). `GuardedWalletRow.withinReach` +uses this group's own leaf's delay, `wallet.account.guardians[position].delay`, +instead of the constant. Each row's supporting line says that delay, because +two of a group's descendants can have made it different promises. + +**The detail screens.** The subgroup rows that say *Guarded wallet* since the +policy plan's Phase 8 become *Guarded wallet, 144 blocks, about 1 day*, read off +the certificate's first guardian. + +**The send screen**, for a guardian spending from a descendant. Its +"spendable" line already counts only coins past this leaf's lock, through +`GroupSpendBuilder.lockOf`. It gains the delay in words, so a guardian looking +at a balance of zero learns why. + +The six strings that say `%1$d confirmations` are replaced, not edited: each +takes the `delayText` as a `%1$s`, or is split into a title and the per-guardian +rows. + +**Tests**: `GroupWalletViewModelJvmTest` and a `GuardedWalletRow` test with two +guardians at 12 and 4,320, where a coin with 100 confirmations is within the +first's reach and not the second's. + +--- + +## Phase 8 — docs, and checking it on the emulators + +- [group-wallet-guardians.md](./group-wallet-guardians.md): *Why 12, and why for + everybody* becomes *Why a delay, and who sets it*. It keeps the reasoning for + a floor, adds the autonomy trade, and links here. The headline's `12` becomes + ``. +- [subgroup-wallet-policy.md](./subgroup-wallet-policy.md): the guarded row on + the picker gains the delay, one sentence. +- [README.md](./README.md): this note's row and a sentence on reading order. +- This note: *Built*, and the table of where the build chose differently. + +By hand, regtest, three emulators: + +1. The root makes a guarded subgroup `M` at 6 blocks, and `M` makes a guarded + subgroup `C` at 20 blocks. +2. `C`'s wallet screen lists `M` at 20 blocks and the root at 6. +3. With a coin in `C` mined 10 blocks deep, the root can spend it and `M` + cannot. At 20 blocks deep, both can. +4. A guardian spend from the root goes through at `nSequence = 6`, and a + hand-built one at 5 is rejected by the regtest node as non-final. + +```bash +./gradlew :composeApp:compileDebugKotlinAndroid :composeApp:jvmTest +``` + +```bash +./gradlew :composeApp:m3Audit +``` + +--- + +## Order and size + +| phase | touches | ships | +|---|---|---| +| 1 | `GuardianDerivation`, `GuardianTag` | dark: the default is still 12 everywhere | +| 2 | tests only | — | +| 3 | `BlockDuration`, the first plurals | dark: nothing shows it yet | +| 4 | DKG proposal tags, `DkgSession`, schema 30 | dark: nothing sets a delay | +| 5 | picker, join gate | **the switch** | +| 6 | certificate, both signers' checks | with 5 | +| 7 | wallet, detail and send screens | before 5 | +| 8 | docs, emulator run | last | + +**Phase 7 should land before Phase 5.** A build that can make a wallet with a +6-block leaf, while its own wallet screen says 12, would be telling a group the +wrong number about its own money. Phases 1-4 and 7 change nothing a user can +choose, so they can go out first. Phases 5 and 6 go together, because a picker +whose number the certificate did not carry would be a number that meant +nothing. + +**Mixed versions.** A parent signer on a build from before Phase 6 compares the +proposal to `grant()` with 12, so it **refuses** any other delay. That is the +safe failure: it never signs a delay it did not check. A group whose signers +are not all updated can still make subgroups at 12, but not at any other delay. +Readers on older builds already build each leaf from its own tag, so they derive +the right addresses and enforce the right sequence. They only show the wrong +number on screen. + +--- + +## What this does not do + +**It does not let the parent change a delay after birth** (D6). A different +delay is a different subgroup. + +**It does not let a middle group change an ancestor's delay** (D1). The root's +terms reach every guarded descendant as the root set them. + +**It does not give an ancestor two delays in one wallet.** One leaf per ancestor, +as before. "This group can take any coin after a week, and everything after a +year" would be two leaves per ancestor and a different tree. + +**It does not offer an absolute lock.** "On 1 January 2027, every coin in this +wallet becomes the root's" is a `OP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY` leaf. It is not a delay +counted from each coin, and it is a different promise about time, with a +different ceiling and different consequences for a child that keeps moving its +coins. + +**It does not make a long delay safe against an active child.** A child that +moves its coins before the lock runs out keeps them out of reach, and the +picker says so. Nothing on mainnet can force coins to stay put without a +covenant, which the guardians note has already said there is none to write. + +## Appendix — what was considered and rejected + +| idea | why not | +|---|---| +| one delay per certificate, for every leaf | lets a middle group rewrite its ancestors' terms (D1) | +| time-based BIP68 locks | a lower ceiling (about 388 days), coarser 512-second steps, and median time past rather than blocks, for no gain | +| a slider over 6 to 65,535 | unusable at the short end, where most choices are | +| a floor of 1 | lets a guardian race the child for a payment one block after it arrives, the thing a delay exists to prevent | +| showing time without blocks | blocks are what the script counts; ten minutes is an average | +| a time estimate on regtest | its blocks come when somebody mines one |